I'm a huge fan of american Idol, but...
Sadly, I was hoping for something a little bit better than this. It's a very original topic and I think that although the idea was good, it could have been performed a lot better.
Not saying it's bad, but the low sound volume and kind of -meh- animation is the reason for the 8. I only watched it to the second contestant before I got bored and shut it off. Maybe the judges talked later in the animation, but what I saw, the responses were fairly boring.
Overall, the main issue with this is the lack of piz-azz. It was quite boring but I did chuckle a few times. The thing about american idol that I love is the wise-cracking judges and humor. Sadly this had neither.
ALSO-another nit-bit; I think this was more like Hollywood week in the since of the stage and background....but because the singers sucked, I would have liked a more audition-like background....meh,
my opinion.
GOOD luck with your next flashes and I will look forward to more from you. Sorry if I ranted.